→ QUICK ANSWER
Many Gilbert tile roofs still have their original underlayment. The tiles look fine. That doesn't mean the roof is fine. Here's why underlayment fails first.

Walk through any neighborhood in Gilbert that went up between 1995 and 2008. The roofs look fine. Intact tiles, no missing pieces, nothing from the street that says "problem." But a lot of those houses are sitting on original felt underlayment. On most East Valley tile roofs, the underlayment wears out long before the tile does.
The tiles last. The layer under them does not. That's the gap most Gilbert homeowners don't find out about until there's a water stain on the bedroom ceiling after a July storm.
Concrete tile roofs in Arizona are long-lasting. What almost nobody explains clearly is that the tiles are not your waterproofing. The underlayment beneath them is. And those two layers are running on completely different clocks.
Felt underlayment, which was standard on most East Valley tile installs from the mid-1990s through the early 2000s, breaks down in Arizona's climate. Synthetic underlayment, which started becoming more common around the mid-2000s, holds up better. Either way, you're replacing the underlayment well before the tiles above it wear out.
So if you're standing in front of a Gilbert home that was built in 2001, you're looking at underlayment that has spent more than two decades under Arizona sun. How it has held up depends on the product and how the roof was ventilated.
The tiles won't tell you any of this. They look exactly the same as they did ten years ago. That's kind of the whole problem.
Tile roofs are a weather-shedding system, not a sealed waterproof barrier. The tiles overlap and channel rain down the slope. That works great when rain falls straight down. But monsoon storms in Gilbert don't always do that. Wind pushes water sideways and upward. A loose tile creates an entry point. That's when the underlayment has to catch what the tiles miss.
In extreme heat, underlayment dries out. Felt becomes brittle. It cracks at the overlaps, particularly on south- and west-facing pitches where UV exposure is heaviest. It tears when tiles shift from thermal expansion, which happens every single day out here when the temperature runs from the high 70s at dawn to 110 by mid-afternoon. Each crack is a path for water to reach the decking.
The space under the tile gets very hot in an Arizona summer, and felt underlayment is not built to absorb that year after year. Synthetic handles the heat stress better, but even the good synthetic products degrade faster here than they would in a milder climate.
The tiles above stay intact because concrete and clay are designed specifically to handle intense sun and heat. The felt beneath them was not designed for the same mission. That's the mismatch that catches homeowners off guard.
Gilbert exploded during a very specific window. A big slice of Gilbert neighborhoods went up in the late 1990s and 2000s.
That puts a lot of those roofs right in the window where felt underlayment has run its clock.
Neighborhoods like Power Ranch, Finley Farms, Val Vista Lakes, and the developments that went up along Higley and Greenfield during that run are all in this zone. Not every house. But enough that if you live in one of those neighborhoods and haven't had a roofing contractor look underneath your tiles in the last few years, you're operating on incomplete information.
A common pattern: a homeowner has lived there 8 or 10 years. The roof looks solid. They get their first real monsoon leak and expect one tile to be replaced. Pull a few tiles near the entry point, and the underlayment can be dried out and cracked across a wide area. The tile wasn't the failure. The tile was the last thing to move before water found the path.
That story is not unusual in Gilbert in 2026. It's something we see often.
You can't fully diagnose underlayment from the street. But you can spot signals that justify getting a professional up there.
From outside, stand back and use binoculars. Look for tiles that have shifted or cracked. One tile sitting noticeably higher or lower than the surrounding field means the underlayment beneath it has been exposed, and wind-driven rain has had a direct path to the decking. Look along the eave line too. If you can see gray or black material showing through gaps between tiles, that's deteriorated underlayment visible from the ground and it needs attention.
From the attic, go up on a bright day and turn off your flashlight. If you see daylight coming through the roof deck boards, that's a problem. Look for brown staining on the underside of the decking, moisture in the insulation, or a musty smell. Any of those means water has been finding its way through for a while.
From inside the house, a ceiling stain that shows up during or after a monsoon is almost always a roof issue. Important thing to know: the stain on your ceiling is rarely directly under the entry point. Water travels along rafter framing before it drips through drywall. The entry point can be two or three feet away from where you see the stain.
The age test is the simplest one. If your underlayment has never been replaced, an inspection is warranted regardless of how the roof looks. The roof looking fine does not mean the underlayment is fine.
This is something a lot of homeowners don't realize when they first hear "underlayment replacement." The tiles don't have to go in the trash. Underlayment replacement means removing the tiles, stripping off the old underlayment, installing new material, and resetting the tiles. If those tiles are structurally intact, most of them come back down on the new underlayment.
That's a very different cost picture than a full tear-off and replacement. Reusing existing tiles costs significantly less.
But there are situations where replacement makes more sense. If the existing tiles are cracked or brittle across a large area, if the profile is discontinued and you can't match the tiles that break during removal, or if there's already deck damage that requires full access, buying new tile is the right call.
When we do an underlayment-only job, we plan for some breakage during tile removal. That's normal. We order additional matching tile to cover it. The homeowner ends up with a new underlayment, re-set original tiles, and a handful of new matching tiles where breakage happened. If everything was installed with a current common profile, this approach works well.
One thing worth checking before any job: whether your tile profile is still in production. Some of the profiles common in Gilbert in the late 1990s and early 2000s have been discontinued. If that's the case for your roof, it's worth knowing before you need to replace underlayment, not after.
Here's how the clock actually runs on a tile roof in the East Valley.
Concrete tiles: long-lasting in Arizona. The heat fades the color over time and surface absorption increases on concrete tile as it ages, but the structural integrity holds up well under UV and the daily thermal cycling we get out here.
Underlayment: On most East Valley tile roofs, the underlayment wears out long before the tile does. Synthetic holds up better than felt under heat stress and UV.
Flashing and caulk: a different clock entirely. Sealants and flashing caulk break down faster under Arizona UV. Flashing failure is often the first leak source on a tile roof, even before the underlayment fully gives out. If your roof is leaking and the tiles look fine, check the flashing around pipe boots, vents, and where the roof meets any walls.
The deck: when underlayment fails and water reaches the plywood or OSB decking, delamination starts. That's when the repair scope gets expensive. Getting to it at the underlayment stage is always cheaper than waiting until the deck is soft.
A Gilbert home built in 2001 with felt underlayment may already need it replaced. A home built in 2001 with synthetic depends on product quality. The tiles on both roofs look the same from the street.
That's the situation. Worth knowing about before the monsoon hits.
If you want to understand the full picture of what's happening beneath your tile on a pre-monsoon checklist, take a look at our pre-monsoon roof inspection checklist for East Valley homeowners. And if your tiles look perfect but you're already getting leaks, read why a tile roof leaks when every tile looks fine before you call anyone.
If you haven't had a professional look under your tiles in the last few years, honest answer is: you don't know what's under there. The roof looking fine from the street tells you about the tiles. It doesn't tell you about the felt that's been baking underneath them for years.
We're based in Gilbert. Book an inspection with us anywhere in the East Valley, including Gilbert, Chandler, Mesa, and Queen Creek. No pressure, no sales pitch. If the underlayment is holding, we'll tell you that. If it isn't, we'll tell you what your options are and what the job actually involves.
Call us at (602) 806-6806. We answer 24/7.
What an underlayment replacement involves, with your existing tile reset rather than replaced, is laid out step by step on our tile roof repair and underlayment replacement in Gilbert page.
WRITTEN BY
Tuuta Pulotu is the CEO and co-founder of All Storm Roofing. He was born and raised in Arizona. His mom is from Hawaii, his dad from Tonga, and Tuuta grew up in the trades working alongside his father, who's been running a concrete crew in the Valley. Before founding All Storm in 2022, Tuuta spent years in solar sales. Long enough to watch too many East Valley homeowners get pushed into roof decisions they didn't fully understand. He started All Storm to flip that conversation: be the contractor who tells homeowners what's actually going on with their roof, even when the truth costs him the job. He runs All Storm out of Gilbert, where he lives with his wife and four kids. AZ ROC #345156. TAMKO Pro Diamond Certified. The only TAMKO Pro Diamond Certified contractor in Arizona.